CJEU follows AG Opinion and rules that the authorization under Article 17(1) of the DSM Directive also covers acts of reproduction

· DSM Directive,OCSSPs,Article 17,Austro-Mechana,copyright

Article 17(1) of the DSM Directive [IPKat posts here] requires online content sharing service providers (OCSSPs) to secure the authorization of relevant rightholders “in order to communicate to the public or make available to the public works or other subject matter.”

Section image

You simply cannot communicate what's not in you

Earlier this week – correctly and unsurprisingly – the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) answered in the affirmative in Austro-Mechana, C-579/24, thus endorsing the earlier Opinion of Advocate General (AG) Emiliou [IPKat here].

Let’s see how the Court reasoned (note that the judgment is not yet available in English).

Is a distinct authorization required to undertake acts of reproduction?

The first question referred by Austria’s Federal Administrative Court asked whether an OCSSP needs a distinct authorization to store protected content. To address it, the CJEU considered it necessary to determine if such an activity could be regarded as being relevant under Article 2 of the InfoSoc Directive.

Having recalled the broad notion of ‘reproduction’ under Article 2 [readers are recommended, to this end, to take a look at the very recent Opinion of AG Szpunar in Like Company, C-250/25, including his remarks regarding the technical – as opposed to functional – understanding of ‘reproduction’ under EU copyright: IPKat here], the CJEU concluded that the memorization of protected content on an OCCSP’s server is in fact an act of reproduction. Such a position, added the Court, also complies with international law, notably the Agreed Statement to Article 1(4) WCT and Article 9 of the Berne Convention.

Having established that, the CJEU ruled out that the temporary copies exemption under Article 5(1) of the InfoSoc Directive would apply, upon consideration that the relevant requirements therein are cumulative and the first one (temporary character) would not be fulfilled in the case at hand.

Following these considerations, the CJEU noted the ambiguous wording of Article 17(1), which could be interpreted either way, but ultimately considered that an interpretation which would leave the right of reproduction outside the scope of Article 17 would contribute to legal uncertainty by requiring OCSSPs to follow two distinct regimes - the InfoSoc+DSA (having regard to the hosting safe harbour) and the DSM Directive ones.

It follows that the authorization that OCSSPs must seek to obtain from relevant rightholders (in accordance with the best efforts standards of Article 17(4)(a)) encompasses acts that are relevant under both Article 3 and Article 2 of the InfoSoc Directive. Such a position, according to the Court, also complies with the fair balance mandate that inter alia informs the DSM Directive.

Do users-uploaders need to seek their own authorization to upload third-party protected content?

The Court then considered whether users require a self-standing authorization to upload content that incorporates third-party copyright works or protected subject-matter onto OCSSPs.

To address this it was necessary to consider the scope of Article 17(2), which provides that – under certain conditions (users shall only be covered “when they are not acting on a commercial basis or where their activity does not generate significant revenues”) – the authorization obtained by OCSSPs also extends to users. In sync with the previous response, the Court concluded that such an authorization would not only encompass Article 3 of the InfoSoc Directive acts but also acts of reproduction undertaken by users under Article 2 of that directive.

Comment

The judgment aligns with the Opinion of AG Emiliou: in my view, the Court could not decide otherwise.

As I also discussed in my article-by-article commentary to the provisions of the DSM Directive, it is true that the undertaking of restricted acts other than those under Article 3 of the InfoSoc Directive, including acts of reproduction engaged in uploading processes, are not expressly covered by the authorization obtained by the OCSSP. That said, contrary to the view that some commentators held at the time when the commentary was released (2021), my position was that

in order not to deprive Article 17(2) of its effet utile, it is preferable to regard the authorization obtained by an OCSSP as also covering the acts of reproduction performed by users when they upload the content that an OCSSP subsequently stores and makes available to the public, insofar as such acts are functional and propaedeutic to the doing of the acts under Article 3 of the InfoSoc Directive.

In all of this, it is worth recalling a key point, that is that the authorization referred to in Article 17(1)(2) is the minimum one: an authorization obtained by an OCCSP must at least have the scope indicated therein. Nothing prevents rightholders and OCSSPs to negotiate an authorization with a broader scope, including having regard to relevant exclusive rights engaged in OCSSPs’ activities and the types of users covered by it.

[Originally published on The IPKat on 14 November 2026]